Should a free trial ask for a card up front? A bird in the hand, on fair terms

Alex · Founder of Magpie AI
Published · 8 min read

In short
Ask for a card up front only when the product shows its worth within the trial and you'll say plainly, beside the button, what is charged after it, on which day and how to cancel. Seven days is a sound length for most software. UK rules drafted for 1 January 2027 also want a reminder before the first charge.
Contents
A card up front makes sense when the product proves itself inside the trial and you're open about the charge that follows. Ask for one on a product that takes a month to understand, or tuck the charge into grey type under the button, and you'll get fewer sign-ups plus a list of people paying for something they forgot they started.
I went looking for a controlled test of card against no card and didn't find one. There are plenty of companies writing up their own funnels, but none of it is a study I'd lean on.
What does exist is a big field test of trials that renew by themselves against trials that end by themselves, which is pretty much the choice a card up front forces.
What a card up front does to sign-ups#
It cuts them. Klaus Miller, Navdeep Sahni and Avner Strulov-Shlain offered 1.4 million readers of a European newspaper a promotional subscription that either rolled into a paid plan unless cancelled or ended on its own unless renewed, and everyone gave payment details at the start in both versions (so the card itself wasn't the difference, only what happened by default). In their January 2026 paper, offering the auto-renewing version "lowers subscriptions take-up by 35% and total subscribers by 23% over 20 months".
For a few months after the promotion the renewing version had more people paying, and its cumulative revenue ran about 2.5 cents higher for each reader offered it, a gap that was no longer significant by month 16. More than half of those auto-renewed subscribers never visited the site again after the promotion, though. By month 12 the version that made people choose had more subscribers.
So a good share of readers saw the catch coming and stayed away. The authors suggest that a business which can credibly promise easy cancelling and timely reminders "might end up with more consumers and larger revenues", and I think that's the line to take from it.
When I'd ask for the card#
When a buyer can see the product work within days and already means to pay if it does, such as an uptime monitor or a tool that books meetings, the card filters out the idly curious and the charge on day 8 lands on someone who wanted it.
I'd skip it when the value takes weeks to show up, or needs setup and a pile of data before anything happens, or when most visitors arrive cold from search and have never heard of you. That's a lot of trust to ask for on a first visit. Whether you'd lose 35% of starts, as the newspaper did, I honestly don't know; a software buyer isn't a newspaper reader, and nobody has published the test.
How long a free trial should be#
Seven days is a sound default for software. Hema Yoganarasimhan, Ebrahim Barzegary and Abhishek Pani ran a field test with one software company across six markets, the UK and the US among them, giving 337,724 new users a 7, 14 or 30-day trial at random. The 7-day trial won 5.59% more subscriptions than the company's standard 30 days, and 14 days did no better than 30 (Management Science, 2023).
Why would less time sell more? Their data pointed at the end of the trial. People who went quiet for a long stretch near the end converted less, and a 30-day trial leaves plenty of room to go quiet.
Experienced users did gain from longer trials. Beginners did better with short ones.
The newspaper test leans faintly the other way. Four weeks against two lifted subscriptions by 4 to 5% during the promotion, though the authors found that gap wasn't statistically significant.
I'd start at seven days and move only for a reason you can name, like a product whose first useful result needs a fortnight of data. Three days feels too tight once the reminder rules below apply, because the reminder has to land with time left to read it and act.
What your site has to say before the trial starts#
Beside the button, before anyone commits, say what the trial turns into and when. For trials sold to consumers in the UK that's set to become law. The government's draft guidance, published in October 2026, calls a free or cheaper trial a "concessionary period" and lists the key information a buyer has to be given before signing up:
- that the plan renews and charges unless they end it before the trial is over, and on which day the first charge lands
- how much that charge is, and how often it repeats
- how to end the plan, and any notice needed
- when you'll send reminders
- their right to cancel in the cooling-off period
Online, it has to be readable during sign-up without clicking a link, set apart from everything else and as close as possible to the moment they commit. And the last button has to make plain that pressing it means paying, or the buyer isn't bound.
Here's a made-up social scheduling tool at pagepost.example, the line under its button before and after:
| Before | After |
|---|---|
| Start free trial, then cancel any time | 7 days free, then £12 a month from 24 November. We email you 3 days before. Cancel in Settings, any time |
The second one is three times as long and may leave whoever guards the page's whitespace feeling a bit henpecked. I'd still ship it. The line under the button is where the last doubt gets answered, as it is for the words on the button itself, and the price after the trial should match the price on your pricing table to the penny, with yearly plans said as yearly and never dressed up as monthly.
The reminder before the first charge#
Send it by email or another message the buyer can find again later. The UK guidance rules out pop-ups and push notifications that vanish, wants the purpose plain from the subject line, and wants the amount, the date, how to cancel and the date by which they need to act.
How far ahead is up to you, as long as your key information says it and the buyer gets "a real opportunity" to decide and cancel first.
After the first payment there's also a 14-day renewal cooling-off period. The buyer can still cancel in it, and may be owed a refund.
Which makes a charge from someone who forgot about the trial money you shouldn't count before it hatches, since they can cancel any time in the fortnight that follows and may get the money back (and I'd expect plenty to, the moment they spot it on a statement).
Cancelling has to be straightforward, at any time, and online if signing up was. I'd use a labelled button or a page in their account. An email address alone doesn't count, and the guidance doubts a compulsory "why are you leaving" form would either.
For what it's worth, Magpie's own plans start this way: seven days, the card at checkout, a reminder before the first charge, then 14 days to withdraw.
Where the UK and US rules stand today#
Each of these was checked on 17 November 2026, and at least two of them could change within months. I'm not a lawyer, and none of this is legal advice.
| Rule | Status on 17 November 2026 |
|---|---|
| UK, DMCC Act 2024 subscription rules | Passed, not yet in force. Draft regulations laid on 18 October 2026, set to start on 1 January 2027 for contracts made from then on, still waiting for both Houses to approve |
| US, Restore Online Shoppers' Confidence Act | In force since 2010 |
| US, FTC click-to-cancel rule (2024) | Vacated by the Eighth Circuit on 8 July 2025; the old rule restored on 12 February 2026 |
| US, a new FTC rule | Comments asked for in March 2026; no proposed rule published |
Once the UK rules apply, the Competition and Markets Authority can fine a business up to £300,000 or 10% of its global turnover, whichever is higher. A House of Lords committee drew the House's special attention to the regulations on 3 November 2026, so 1 January 2027 is the plan and not yet the law.
The US is messier. The 2024 click-to-cancel rule never took effect, because the court vacated it for "procedural deficiencies" in how the FTC made it rather than for anything it said, and the older rule put back in February 2026 covers only prenotification plans; the FTC's March notice says it doesn't cover "continuity plans, automatic renewals, and trial conversions". So the law that bites is the Restore Online Shoppers' Confidence Act. Since 2010 it has covered anything sold online with a charge that repeats unless the buyer acts. You have to disclose every material term before taking billing details, get express informed consent before charging, and give a simple way to stop the charges. The FTC also names California, Colorado, Vermont and Virginia among states with rules of their own.
If your site gives the UK's five points beside the button, I think you've covered the main disclosures in both countries, though consent and the way out still live in your checkout and account pages, and a state you sell into may want its own wording on top.
Questions people ask#
Do the UK rules apply if I only sell to businesses?#
No, they cover subscriptions sold to consumers, not to businesses. If you sell to both, your sales to consumers are covered.
Is a £1 trial treated differently from a free one?#
Not really. The guidance counts a cheaper trial as a concessionary period too, so you'd still owe buyers the price after it, the date of the first full charge, the reminder and the cooling-off period. I'd guess some teams pick a £1 trial thinking it gets them out of the rules, and it doesn't, and you've added a charge to explain on top.
Can the reminder be a notice inside the app?#
Not on its own. It has to be something the buyer can keep and read again, so an email or a text.
Sources
- Miller, Sahni and Strulov-Shlain, Sophisticated consumers with inertia: long-term implications from a large-scale field experiment (working paper, January 2026) (opens in a new tab)
- Yoganarasimhan, Barzegary and Pani, Design and evaluation of optimal free trials (Management Science, 2023) (opens in a new tab)
- Department for Business, Innovation, Science and Trade, Guidance on the subscription contracts rules (draft, October 2026) (opens in a new tab)
- Draft Consumer Subscription Contracts (Cancellation and Information) Regulations 2026 (opens in a new tab)
- UK Parliament, the draft regulations' progress through Parliament (opens in a new tab)
- Digital Markets, Competition and Consumers Act 2024, Part 4 Chapter 2 (opens in a new tab)
- Restore Online Shoppers' Confidence Act, 15 U.S.C. 8403 (opens in a new tab)
- US Court of Appeals for the Eighth Circuit, Custom Communications v. FTC, No. 24-3137 (8 July 2025) (opens in a new tab)
- Federal Trade Commission, Negative Option Rule restored to its pre-2024 form (Federal Register, 12 February 2026) (opens in a new tab)
- Federal Trade Commission, Negative Option Rule: advance notice of proposed rulemaking (Federal Register, 13 March 2026) (opens in a new tab)

About the author
Alex · Founder of Magpie AI
Alex founded Magpie AI and writes about what turns a landing page's visitors into customers, drawing on what its audits find on real sites, from the first screen to the checkout


