Do your site's promises match your terms? No cuckoos in the small print

· Founder of Magpie AI

Published · 9 min read

In short

They have to agree. "Cancel any time", "we never share your data", a money-back guarantee and "no hidden fees" are promises, and UK and US law judge the impression your site gives, so a clause in your terms that quietly takes one back doesn't fix it. Read each promise against your terms and privacy policy, then change whichever side is wrong.

Contents

Your site and your terms were probably written months apart, by different people or by the same person in two very different moods. The landing page got rewritten in launch week. The terms came from a template, or from a friend's startup, and nobody has opened them since.

So the page says "Cancel any time" and the terms say an annual plan runs to the end of its year. The page says "We never share your data" and the privacy policy lists four advertising partners. Each one reads fine on its own, and together they don't hold.

I'm not a lawyer and none of this is legal advice. What follows is what the regulators' own documents say, checked on 17 November 2026, and how I'd go through a site to find the gaps before a buyer does.

Why a clause in your terms doesn't fix a promise on your site#

Regulators in both countries look at the impression the whole site gives, and a promise in large type isn't cancelled by a clause most buyers will never open.

In the US, section 5 of the FTC Act declares "unfair or deceptive acts or practices in or affecting commerce" unlawful. The Federal Trade Commission's Policy Statement on Deception, a letter to Representative John Dingell dated 14 October 1983, says what that means. It finds deception where something is "likely to mislead the consumer acting reasonably in the circumstances, to the consumer's detriment". It judges "the net impression", "the entire mosaic, rather than each tile separately". And it says plainly that "written disclosures or fine print may be insufficient to correct a misleading representation." Express claims, the words you chose to put on the page, are presumed to matter to buyers.

In the UK the same idea sits in the Digital Markets, Competition and Consumers Act 2024, whose unfair commercial practices part came into force on 6 April 2025. Section 226 counts false or misleading information as a misleading action, and adds that "an overall presentation may be deceiving even if the information it contains is true." Section 227 says leaving out material information includes giving it "in such a way that the consumer is unlikely to see it".

The Competition and Markets Authority's guidance (CMA207, updated 18 November 2025) has an example that reads a lot like a pricing page. A shop advertises big discounts on televisions, and "a footnote in very small font explains that only a very small number of the televisions are on sale". The advert may be factually correct, the CMA says, and if the average buyer wouldn't notice the footnote and would have decided differently with it, they've been misled. Swap the footnote for clause 14.3 of your terms and you've got the same problem.

The promises that come apart most often#

Four lines turn up on a lot of software sites, and each has its own way of drifting away from the documents behind it.

"Cancel any time"#

I'd guess this is the line most often pinched, magpie fashion, from a rival's pricing page without a look at your own billing. Read your terms for a minimum term, a notice period, cancelling by email only, or a yearly plan that can't be ended early. If any of those are there, the line on the page is wrong, or at least incomplete, and it often sits right under the button, where it does the most persuading.

For trials, the UK's subscription rules (drafted to start on 1 January 2027) add their own list of what must be said before a buyer commits, which I've gone through in the article on free trials that take a card.

"We never share your data"#

Privacy promises are where I'd look first. When our full report read the AI products that led a launch site in October 2026 against their own privacy policies and terms, six of the nine contradictions it found were about data, meaning what was stored, for how long, where, and who else got to see it.

The FTC case people tend to point to is BetterHelp. On 2 March 2023 the FTC said the online counselling service had "promised consumers that it would not use or disclose their personal health data except for limited purposes", at several points in its sign-up, and had then passed data to Facebook, Snapchat, Criteo and Pinterest for advertising. Under the proposed order it was to pay $7.8 million to consumers and be banned from sharing health data for advertising.

Your privacy policy has to say who you share data with anyway. The ICO's guidance on the right to be informed lists "who it will be shared with" among the things people must be told, wants it "concise, transparent, intelligible, easily accessible", and says "you must regularly review, and where necessary, update your privacy information." My guess is that the policy is usually the more honest document, and the words on your site are what need softening. If an analytics script or an ad pixel sends your visitors' data to another company, that company is who the policy should be naming, so the trackers your cookie banner answers for belong in the same check.

"30-day money-back guarantee"#

The US guides on guarantees are short and blunt. The words "Money Back Guarantee" should be used "only if the seller or manufacturer, as the case may be, refunds the full purchase price of the advertised product at the purchaser's request", and any "material limitations or conditions" have to be disclosed so prospective buyers notice and understand them (16 CFR 239.3). A refund "at our sole discretion" in your terms, or one that excludes the first month, doesn't sit with a guarantee badge on the pricing table.

In the UK there's a trap going the other way. Schedule 20 of the 2024 Act bans "presenting rights given to consumers by law as a distinctive feature of the trader's offer". The CMA's example is a shop boasting of a 14-day no-questions refund that buyers already have under the cancellation rules. If your "14-day money-back guarantee" is the legal cooling-off period with a badge on it, I'd either make the guarantee longer than the law gives or stop presenting it as a perk. Banned practices can carry penalties of up to £300,000 or 10% of worldwide turnover, whichever is higher, according to the same guidance.

"No hidden fees"#

The fee doesn't have to be hidden in a sinister way to break this one. A card surcharge in the terms, a set-up fee that appears at checkout, VAT added for consumers after the price was shown. Section 230 of the UK Act says "the total price of a product includes any fees, taxes, charges or other payments that the consumer will necessarily incur", and the same Act lists the total price among the material information an invitation to buy has to give. How to show prices honestly, fees and yearly billing included, has its own article.

Hardly anyone reads the small print, and it still matters#

Very few buyers read terms. Yannis Bakos, Florencia Marotta-Wurgler and David Trossen tracked 48,154 monthly visitors to 90 software companies' sites and found that only one or two in every 1,000 shoppers opened the licence agreement at all, and most of those who did read only a small part of it (Journal of Legal Studies, 2014).

That cuts both ways. It's exactly why the FTC and CMA won't let the small print do the work of correcting the headline, because almost nobody gets that far. My guess is that the one or two in a thousand who do read it are the careful ones about to sign up for the biggest plan, or the ones who've just been charged and are hunting for the cancel clause. That's nobody's study, only how it looks from here. Either way, those are the people who'll sing like canaries about a broken promise in a review, and I'd bet louder than a happy customer mentions a kept one.

There's a newer reader too, and I'm less sure how much weight to give it. People now ask AI assistants whether a product is safe to sign up for, and an assistant that can read your privacy policy can quote it straight back at them.

How to check your own site in an afternoon#

Copy out every promise your site makes, then find the clause that backs each one. For most sites it's a slow afternoon, I'd guess, and it goes a lot faster with the terms and the page open side by side.

  1. Collect the promises from the first screen, the line under each button, the pricing table and its footnotes, the FAQ and the footer. Badges count ("GDPR compliant", "Bank-level security").
  2. For each one, search the terms and the privacy policy for its subject: cancel, refund, share, sell, retain, fee, charge.
  3. Mark each promise as backed, contradicted, or not mentioned at all.
  4. Fix whichever side is wrong. Sometimes that's the page (the policy is accurate, the marketing got ahead of it), sometimes the terms (a template clause you never meant).

Here's how that might look for a made-up note-taking app at minutes.example:

On the siteIn its terms or policyWhat I'd change
Cancel any timeAnnual plans run to the end of the term and are not refunded"Monthly plans cancel any time; yearly plans run to their renewal date"
We never share your dataWe share usage data with analytics and advertising partnersDrop the ad partner, or say "We never sell your data" and name the analytics provider
30-day money-back guaranteeRefunds are at our discretionRewrite the refund clause to give the full price back within 30 days on request
No hidden feesA 3% card processing fee is added at checkoutPut the fee in the price shown, or stop charging it

The "not mentioned" ones are worth a second look. A promise about how long you keep recordings, with nothing in the policy about retention, usually means the policy is the template and nobody filled that part in.

Magpie's full report does this read too. It finds your privacy policy and terms from your own links, sets the site's promises against them, and keeps a quote from a document only where the exact words are there, linked to the place in the document where the clause sits. Ordinary terms, such as a right to end accounts for abuse, aren't treated as contradictions.

Questions people ask#

Is a template privacy policy fine?#

As a starting point, yes. The trouble is that a template describes some imaginary business, often one with more partners and more tracking than yours, or fewer. Go through it line by line and make it describe what your site actually runs, then check the page against that.

Should I change my site or my terms?#

Change whichever one describes your business wrongly. If the policy lists an ad pixel you really do run, the promise on your site has to go, or the pixel does. I'd lean towards fixing the practice where you can, honestly, because a promise like "we never share your data" sells well and you'd keep it.

Does this apply if I only sell to businesses?#

The UK rules quoted here protect consumers, so selling only to businesses takes you out of those. I'd still fix the gap. A buyer at another company who reads "cancel any time" on your site and then finds a 12-month term in the contract isn't going to trust much else you say, and that's a poor start to any renewal conversation.

Sources

  1. Federal Trade Commission, Policy Statement on Deception (14 October 1983) (opens in a new tab)
  2. Federal Trade Commission Act, section 5, 15 U.S.C. 45 (opens in a new tab)
  3. Digital Markets, Competition and Consumers Act 2024, section 226, misleading actions (opens in a new tab)
  4. Digital Markets, Competition and Consumers Act 2024, section 227, misleading omissions (opens in a new tab)
  5. Digital Markets, Competition and Consumers Act 2024, section 230, material information (opens in a new tab)
  6. Digital Markets, Competition and Consumers Act 2024, Schedule 20, banned practices (opens in a new tab)
  7. Competition and Markets Authority, Unfair commercial practices guidance, CMA207 (updated 18 November 2025) (opens in a new tab)
  8. Federal Trade Commission, FTC to ban BetterHelp from revealing consumers' data (2 March 2023) (opens in a new tab)
  9. Guides for the Advertising of Warranties and Guarantees, 16 CFR 239.3 (opens in a new tab)
  10. Information Commissioner's Office, The right to be informed (opens in a new tab)
  11. Bakos, Marotta-Wurgler and Trossen, Does Anyone Read the Fine Print? (Journal of Legal Studies, 2014) (opens in a new tab)

About the author

· Founder of Magpie AI

Alex founded Magpie AI and writes about what turns a landing page's visitors into customers, drawing on what its audits find on real sites, from the first screen to the checkout

Related articles

Fix what loses you customers.Fix what loses you customers. Then bring more of them in

  • Free score, no sign‑upNo sign‑up
  • No credit card neededNo card needed