Comparing your product with rivals on your site. Rivals watch like hawks

Alex · Founder of Magpie AI
Published · 9 min read

In short
Yes, you can. UK, EU and US rules all allow a comparison with a named rival when it's true and like for like: the same kind of product, features buyers care about, figures as they stand today, and a way to check each one. "Cheapest", "#1" and "the only" are read as claims about the whole market, so they need evidence covering all of it.
Contents
Take a made-up staff rota app at rotafy.example. Its pricing page has a table with Rotafy and two named rivals across the top, twelve rows down the side, and a tick in every one of Rotafy's cells. The rivals get four ticks each and eight blanks. It looks like a clean win, and it's very close to the shape the UK's advertising regulator has ruled against twice since 2023, both times after a rival complained.
So yes, you can compare yourself with rivals by name, on your own site, in the UK, the EU and the US. What gets a comparison pulled is a buyer being unable to check it, and the people most likely to read your table line by line are the rivals in it.
Naming a rival is allowed, on conditions#
In the UK the conditions sit in regulation 4 of the Business Protection from Misleading Marketing Regulations 2008 (opens in a new tab), last amended on 6 April 2025. A comparison has to set products side by side that meet "the same needs or intended for the same purpose", and compare "material, relevant, verifiable and representative features" of them, price included. It mustn't confuse anyone about whose product is whose, denigrate the rival, or take unfair advantage of the reputation of its trade mark. The EU's Directive 2006/114/EC uses the same words in Article 4, and the UK's advertising code repeats them as rules 3.33 to 3.43.
That code has covered what a company says on its own website since 2011, so a comparison page is held to it as an advert would be. I'm not a lawyer, and none of this is legal advice, but the rules and rulings below are short enough to read for yourself.
The US is warmer about the whole thing. The Federal Trade Commission's 1979 policy statement (16 CFR 14.15) "encourages the naming of, or reference to" competitors, "but requires clarity, and, if necessary, disclosure to avoid deception of the consumer". It goes further than the UK in one place, saying "disparaging advertising is permissible so long as it is truthful and not deceptive", where the UK regulation lists not discrediting or denigrating a rival as a condition of its own, beside being true.
Whether a comparison is worth making at all is a separate question, and the evidence is old and a bit thin. Dhruv Grewal and colleagues pooled studies of comparative adverts in 1997 and found they won more attention, better memory of the brand and stronger intentions to buy than adverts comparing with no one. People also believed the advertiser less and liked the advert less, and new brands comparing themselves with established ones seemed to gain most. That's adverts rather than landing pages, so I'd take one thing from it. A comparison costs you some trust as it lands, and facts a buyer can check are the only way I know of to earn it back.
What a fair comparison table holds#
The two rulings are worth reading in full, because they're the rota table above with the names changed. On 14 June 2023 the Advertising Standards Authority ruled against a blog post on a company's own site that compared its CRM tool with a named rival and one unnamed one. Every feature was ticked for the advertiser and far fewer for the others. The ASA said the rival's unticked features would be read as "not available", and the advertiser "did not provide any evidence in relation to RoboReception's capabilities". A note at the top telling readers features might have changed and to check with each provider didn't save it.
On 10 June 2026 it was an estate agent's leaflet and Facebook post, nine rows, all nine ticked for the agent and two for each of three rivals. Some rows were things the rivals offered too ("the competitors also offered personalised sale boards"), and "Skilled negotiations by an agent who knows your home" was a matter of opinion dressed as a feature. The table gave no sources and no date either, which was a breach on its own.
Both tables made the same mistake. A blank cell under a rival's name says "they don't have it", and not finding something on a rival's site doesn't mean the rival lacks it. A row you couldn't check is a row to leave out, or one to fill with what you did find and where.
Choose the rows buyers weigh, rather than the ones that happen to flatter you. A table you win twelve rows to nil has been built to feather your own nest, and I think most readers can tell. Kate Moran and Taylor Dykes at Nielsen Norman Group wrote in 2024 that inconsistent content is "the biggest problem with most comparison tables", and advised five items at most, with every row labelled, since a tick can't stand alone. That's expert review rather than a test, but it matches what the rulings punish.
Here's the rotafy.example table rebuilt, against two made-up rivals at shiftgrid.example and teamrota.example:
| Rotafy | ShiftGrid | TeamRota | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Price for 20 staff, billed monthly | £60 a month | £80 a month | £45 a month, up to 25 staff |
| Shift swaps from the phone app | Yes | Yes | Yes |
| Payroll export | Xero and Sage | Xero | Not listed on its site |
| Free plan | Up to 5 staff | None listed | Up to 10 staff |
Under it, one line says each figure comes from that product's own pricing page on 3 November 2026, with a link to each. TeamRota is cheaper, and the table says so. Prices are compared at one team size and one billing period, the same care showing your own prices asks for, since the UK code's rule 3.38 wants the basis of any price comparison made clear.
Make every figure checkable#
The ASA's guidance on verifiability says a comparison should come with "a signpost in the ad to information about the basis of the comparison", and that "the information must also be readily accessible". Results behind a paywall didn't count in a 2020 ruling, and a 2022 footnote at the bottom of the page wasn't a clear enough signpost. It also advises against making a comparison at all when you can't make its data public.
On a website that's easy enough. Date the table, link each rival's figure to the page you took it from, and say in a sentence how you compared (which plan, what team size, monthly or yearly).
Then keep it true. The ASA's guidance on comparisons with named competitors says "marketers must hold up to date evidence", and a rival's pricing page can change on a Tuesday afternoon without telling you. I'd put a monthly reminder in the diary to check every figure in the table, and take the table down if nobody's going to.
"Cheapest", "#1" and "the only" mean the whole market#
An unqualified superlative is read as a claim against every rival you have, so the evidence behind it has to cover all of them as well.
Cheapest. On 16 November 2016 the ASA ruled against a parcel broker's "The Cheapest Parcel Delivery in the UK", which buyers would take to mean it "would always have a cheaper option currently available" than every other parcel service in the UK. Its price match didn't help. The ASA's guidance on lowest price claims (updated 10 November 2025) says they need evidence that you'll "always beat, and not merely match" rivals' prices.
#1. The ASA reads an unqualified "number 1" much as it reads "best-selling" or "leading", and "absolute 'number 1' claims are likely to be understood as entire market comparisons", which usually means unit sales or market share for the whole market. In July 2022 a breakdown service's "The UK's number 1" claim fell because it didn't have its competitors' membership figures. A "#1 rated" claim that only holds after filtering a review site is its own trap, and I go through it in the one about star ratings and review badges, with the ASA's own example.
The only. A product that truly is the only one with some feature is a rare bird, and you'll need the evidence that it is. On 27 February 2019 the ASA ruled against a broadband provider's "only major provider to guarantee no mid-contract price rises", after another provider complained. There was no accepted definition of a "major provider", and the complainant offered fixed prices too. In May 2023 an over-50s life insurer's "only" claim stood, because it showed that every rival's cover came with a waiting period of 12 to 36 months.
So I'd swap the superlative for the measured fact behind it. "£20 a month less than ShiftGrid for 20 staff, billed monthly, on 3 November 2026" is a smaller claim than "cheaper", and it's true, and anyone can check it.
A "vs" page is a comparison too#
A page called "Rotafy vs ShiftGrid" compares you with an identifiable competitor, so every condition above applies to it, the trade mark ones included. Using a rival's name in plain words is how you identify them. Making your page look like theirs, or calling your product a "ShiftGrid clone", runs into the conditions on confusion and on presenting a product "as imitations or replicas", and I wouldn't go near either.
Keep the tone flat and factual. Denigrating a rival is a breach in the UK even where the US would let a true put-down stand, so I'd stick to what a buyer could check for themselves.
And date the page. In my view a vs page goes stale faster than anything else on a site, because nobody looks at it again after launch week, and I'd guess the rival in its title reads it more often than you do.
Before naming anyone, it's worth asking who you're really up against. April Dunford's positioning guide (2021) starts with "What would a customer do if your offering didn't exist?", and the answer is often "Do nothing", which "could mean using a spreadsheet, using a manual process, or hiring an intern to do it." A table set against the spreadsheet your buyers use today needs no rival's facts at all.
What Magpie checks#
Magpie's full report finds up to three rivals through web searches and takes each rival's price only from that rival's own site. It reads your plans beside those prices like with like, and anything it didn't find on a rival's site it treats as unknown, never as missing, which is the line both of those tick tables crossed. The posts it writes for you never name a rival, since a named comparison needs the checking above.
Questions people ask#
Can I compare with "other tools" without naming any?#
You can, though it isn't the safe harbour it looks. The UK code's rule 3.37 says a comparison with an unidentifiable competitor still mustn't mislead, and its elements mustn't be picked to give you an unrepresentative advantage. In July 2019 a firm's "only" claim, shown beside a "Three Best" logo, was read by the ASA as a claim against every relevant competitor, which the firm couldn't back up. So "most rota apps charge per user" needs about the same evidence as a named table, and gives the buyer less to check, which is why I'd rather name the rivals and link their pages.
Do I need a rival's permission to name them?#
No. None of the conditions in regulation 4 is the rival's consent. Their right is to complain, and both tick-table rulings started with a complaint from a competitor.
Sources
- The Business Protection from Misleading Marketing Regulations 2008, regulation 4 (opens in a new tab)
- Directive 2006/114/EC concerning misleading and comparative advertising (opens in a new tab)
- CAP Code, section 3: Misleading advertising (opens in a new tab)
- ASA, Remit: Own websites (2026) (opens in a new tab)
- Federal Trade Commission, 16 CFR 14.15, In regard to comparative advertising (1979, Cornell LII) (opens in a new tab)
- ASA Ruling on The Business Catalyst Ltd (14 June 2023) (opens in a new tab)
- ASA Ruling on RE/MAX Property Specialists (10 June 2026) (opens in a new tab)
- ASA, Comparisons: Identifiable competitors (2026) (opens in a new tab)
- ASA, Comparisons: Verifiability (2026) (opens in a new tab)
- ASA Ruling on Parcel2go.com Ltd (16 November 2016) (opens in a new tab)
- ASA, Lowest price claims and promises (2025) (opens in a new tab)
- ASA, Types of claims: No. 1 (2025) (opens in a new tab)
- ASA, Types of claims: Only and one and only (2024) (opens in a new tab)
- ASA Ruling on TalkTalk Telecom Ltd (27 February 2019) (opens in a new tab)
- Nielsen Norman Group, Comparison Tables for Products, Services, and Features (Kate Moran and Taylor Dykes, 2024) (opens in a new tab)
- Grewal, Kavanoor, Fern, Costley and Barnes, Comparative versus noncomparative advertising: a meta-analysis (RePEc record of the authors' 1998 French edition) (opens in a new tab)
- April Dunford, A Quickstart Guide to Positioning (2021) (opens in a new tab)

About the author
Alex · Founder of Magpie AI
Alex founded Magpie AI and writes about what turns a landing page's visitors into customers, drawing on what its audits find on real sites, from the first screen to the checkout


